Lamar Jackson Vs. Josh Allen: Who Wins MVP 2023?

by Jhon Lennon 49 views

The NFL MVP race is always a hot topic, and in 2023, two names that are constantly in the conversation are Lamar Jackson and Josh Allen. Both quarterbacks possess unique talents and lead teams with Super Bowl aspirations. This article dives deep into comparing these two phenomenal players, analyzing their strengths, weaknesses, statistics, and overall impact on their respective teams to determine who has a better shot at hoisting the MVP trophy.

Lamar Jackson: The Electric Playmaker

When you think about Lamar Jackson, the first word that likely comes to mind is electric. His ability to make defenders miss in the open field is unmatched, and his arm strength allows him to make throws that few other quarterbacks can. Let's break down what makes him a top MVP contender:

  • Rushing Prowess: Lamar isn't just a quarterback; he's a legitimate rushing threat. His speed, agility, and vision make him a nightmare for opposing defenses. The threat of him taking off running forces defenses to account for him on every single play, opening up opportunities for his teammates.
  • Improved Passing: While he entered the league known primarily for his running, Lamar has steadily improved as a passer. He's shown the ability to read defenses, make accurate throws, and deliver the ball downfield. His connection with his receivers has grown stronger each year, making him a more complete quarterback.
  • Leadership: Lamar is the unquestioned leader of the Baltimore Ravens. His teammates respect him, and he has a knack for elevating their play. He brings a certain swagger and confidence to the team that is infectious.
  • Impact on the Ravens: It's no secret that the Ravens' success is directly tied to Lamar's performance. When he's playing at his best, the Ravens are one of the most difficult teams to beat in the NFL. He is their engine, their playmaker, and their driving force.

However, there are some areas where Lamar could improve. His accuracy can sometimes be inconsistent, and he has been prone to turnovers at times. Additionally, his reliance on running can lead to him taking unnecessary hits, which has resulted in injuries in the past. Staying healthy is paramount for Lamar to maintain his MVP candidacy. If Lamar can continue to refine his passing skills, limit turnovers, and stay healthy, he will undoubtedly be a frontrunner for the MVP award. His unique skillset and undeniable impact on the Ravens make him a truly special player to watch.

Josh Allen: The Cannon-Armed Gunslinger

Josh Allen is the modern prototype of an NFL quarterback: big, strong, and with a cannon for an arm. He's capable of making every throw on the field, and his physical presence makes him a force to be reckoned with. Let's analyze why he's a serious MVP candidate:

  • Arm Strength: Allen possesses arguably the strongest arm in the NFL. He can effortlessly launch the ball downfield, making throws that most quarterbacks wouldn't even attempt. This allows the Bills to stretch the field and create explosive plays.
  • Dual-Threat Ability: While not as elusive as Lamar Jackson, Allen is still a capable runner. His size and strength make him difficult to bring down, and he's shown the ability to pick up crucial first downs with his legs.
  • Command of the Offense: Allen has complete command of the Bills' offense. He's able to make adjustments at the line of scrimmage, read defenses, and make the right decisions. His understanding of the game has grown exponentially since he entered the league.
  • Impact on the Bills: Similar to Lamar with the Ravens, the Bills' fortunes rest heavily on Allen's shoulders. When he's playing well, the Bills are a Super Bowl contender. He elevates the play of everyone around him and is the driving force behind their success. He has transformed the Bills into one of the most exciting and dangerous teams in the league.

However, like Lamar, Allen has areas where he can improve. He can sometimes force throws into tight coverage, leading to turnovers. His accuracy can also be inconsistent at times. Additionally, he has a tendency to try to do too much, which can lead to mistakes. If Allen can become more consistent with his decision-making, limit turnovers, and continue to refine his accuracy, he will be a strong contender for the MVP award. His combination of arm strength, athleticism, and leadership make him a truly special quarterback.

Head-to-Head Comparison: Stats and Style

Now, let's get down to the nitty-gritty and compare Lamar Jackson and Josh Allen head-to-head, looking at both their stats and playing styles. Understanding these differences is crucial in assessing their MVP chances.

Statistical Showdown:

It's difficult to make definitive statements without having the full 2023 season stats. However, we can look at career trends and project potential outcomes:

  • Passing Yards: Historically, Josh Allen has typically thrown for more passing yards per season than Lamar Jackson. This is largely due to the Bills' offensive scheme, which relies more heavily on the passing game.
  • Rushing Yards: Lamar Jackson consistently outpaces Josh Allen in rushing yards. His rushing ability is a unique and defining aspect of his game.
  • Touchdowns: Both quarterbacks are capable of scoring touchdowns through the air and on the ground. The edge here often depends on the specific game plan and the performance of their respective supporting casts.
  • Completion Percentage: Josh Allen has generally had a higher completion percentage than Lamar Jackson, reflecting his more traditional passing style.
  • Turnovers: Turnovers are a critical factor in the MVP race. The quarterback who can minimize turnovers will have a significant advantage. This is an area where both players need to be disciplined.

Style of Play:

Their playing styles are distinctly different, adding another layer to the MVP debate:

  • Lamar Jackson: Elusive, dynamic, and unpredictable. He's a master of improvisation and can turn a broken play into a highlight-reel moment. His running ability forces defenses to play differently, creating opportunities for his teammates.
  • Josh Allen: Powerful, aggressive, and confident. He's a gunslinger who isn't afraid to take risks. His arm strength allows him to make throws that few other quarterbacks can, and his physical presence makes him a tough opponent to bring down.

The contrasting styles make this comparison so compelling. Lamar's electrifying runs and improvisational brilliance clash with Josh's cannon arm and aggressive downfield attacks. Ultimately, the MVP voters will likely favor the quarterback whose style translates into more wins and a greater impact on their team's success.

Team Performance: A Crucial Factor

The MVP award is rarely given to a player on a losing team. Therefore, the performance of the Baltimore Ravens and the Buffalo Bills will play a significant role in determining who wins the award. Let's examine the key factors that will influence their team's success:

  • Offensive Line: A strong offensive line is essential for protecting the quarterback and creating running lanes. Both the Ravens and the Bills need their offensive lines to perform at a high level.
  • Receiving Corps: Having reliable receivers who can catch the ball and make plays is crucial for any quarterback's success. The Ravens and Bills need their receivers to step up and contribute consistently.
  • Defense: A solid defense can take pressure off the quarterback and help secure wins. Both teams need their defenses to be able to stop the run, pressure the quarterback, and force turnovers.
  • Coaching: Good coaching can make a significant difference in a team's performance. The Ravens and Bills need their coaching staffs to develop effective game plans and make smart decisions.

If either the Ravens or the Bills struggle as a team, it will be difficult for either Lamar Jackson or Josh Allen to win the MVP award, regardless of their individual statistics. The MVP is often seen as the player who leads their team to the greatest success, so team performance is a critical component of the equation. A Super Bowl run would solidify either quarterback's case, but even a strong playoff showing can be enough to sway voters.

The Verdict: Who Has the Edge?

So, after all this analysis, who has the edge in the 2023 MVP race: Lamar Jackson or Josh Allen? It's a close call, and the answer ultimately depends on a number of factors, including:

  • Individual Performance: Both quarterbacks need to perform at a high level and put up impressive statistics.
  • Team Success: Their respective teams need to win games and compete for a Super Bowl.
  • Health: Both quarterbacks need to stay healthy throughout the season.
  • Narrative: Sometimes, the MVP award comes down to the narrative surrounding a player. If either Lamar or Josh has a compelling story, it could sway voters in their favor.

My Prediction:

As of right now, I would give a slight edge to Josh Allen. His combination of arm strength, athleticism, and leadership, coupled with the Bills' Super Bowl aspirations, makes him a formidable MVP candidate. However, Lamar Jackson is right on his heels, and if he can stay healthy and lead the Ravens to a strong season, he will definitely be in the mix. Ultimately, the MVP race will likely come down to the wire, and it will be exciting to watch these two phenomenal quarterbacks battle it out.

Final Thoughts:

Regardless of who wins the MVP award, both Lamar Jackson and Josh Allen are incredibly talented players who are changing the game of football. They are both exciting to watch, and they are both destined for greatness. As fans, we should appreciate the opportunity to witness these two superstars compete at the highest level.